TL;DR

Staffing agencies make money in two main ways. For temporary and contract workers, they bill you an hourly rate above what they pay the worker and keep the difference, for every hour worked, for as long as the assignment lasts. For permanent placements, they charge a one-time fee, usually a percentage of salary. Buyers often assume the second model applies to the first. It does not, and that misunderstanding is why long contract assignments end up far more expensive than anyone budgeted. Browse vetted candidates

The Two Revenue Models

Temporary or contract staffingDirect hire or permanent placement
How they earnBill rate minus pay rate, every hourOne-time fee on hire
How long it lastsAs long as the assignment runsOnce
Typical structureMarkup on the worker’s hourly payPercentage of first-year salary, or flat
Who employs the workerThe agencyYou

How the Markup Works

On a contract assignment, the agency pays the worker an hourly wage. It then bills you a higher hourly rate. The gap between the two covers three things.

  • Employer costs. Payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance, and any benefits the agency provides as the legal employer.
  • Overhead. Recruiters, account managers, payroll processing, compliance.
  • Profit. What is left after the first two.

Employer costs are substantial on their own. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that benefits make up roughly 30 percent of total employer compensation costs, which explains why markups are much higher than the profit an agency actually keeps.

A Bill Rate, Line by Line

Here is a simplified example for an office role. It is illustrative, because tax rates and insurance costs vary by state and job type.

What the bill rate coversPer hour
Worker’s pay$25.00
Social Security and Medicare, 7.65 percent$1.91
Federal and state unemployment insurance, varies by stateabout $0.60
Workers’ compensation insurance, low for office workabout $0.30
Agency’s gross profitabout $12.19
Bill rate to you, a 60 percent markup$40.00

Of the $15 gap between pay rate and bill rate, about $2.81 is employer cost. The other $12 or so is the agency’s gross profit, roughly 30 percent of the bill rate. Recruiter commissions, sales, payroll staff and offices all come out of that before anything counts as net profit.

Over a full-time year of about 2,080 hours, that $15 gap adds up to around $31,200 for one worker. That is the number to set against a one-time placement fee.

Why the Markup Surprises Buyers

Staffing agency markup versus a one-time placement fee: total cost keeps rising with assignment length while the fee stays flat

The correction worth making: the markup is not a fee. It is a rate, and rates compound with time.

A three-month assignment at a modest markup is reasonable for flexibility. The same worker kept on through the agency for two years means paying that margin on every hour for two years. Nobody signs up for that deliberately. It happens because the assignment keeps getting extended and nobody re-runs the numbers.

Pavago’s pricing page puts staff augmentation at $8,000 to $15,000 a month for as long as someone is embedded, against a one-time placement fee of 3% of first-year salary. The difference is entirely about the time dimension.

What Moves the Markup Up or Down

FactorEffect on the markup
Workers’ compensation riskHigher for warehouse, construction and industrial roles, lower for office work
Skill scarcityHigher for hard-to-fill specialist IT, engineering and healthcare roles
Benefits the agency providesHigher if the agency offers health cover or paid time off
Volume and lengthLower for large contracts and long assignments, which agencies discount to win
Who found the workerMuch lower for payrolling, where you bring the worker and the agency only employs them

With this many variables, a single “typical markup” figure is not much use. The better habit is to ask for the pay rate and do the subtraction yourself.

Other Ways Agencies Earn

Hourly markups and placement fees are the bulk of it, but most agencies have other revenue lines.

  • Conversion fees. Charged when you move a contract worker onto your own payroll early.
  • Payrolling. You recruit the person, and the agency employs and pays them for a smaller markup. Often used to avoid setting up payroll in a new state.
  • Managed services. Large employers pay a fee for the agency to run their whole contingent workforce, including other suppliers.
  • Recruitment process outsourcing. A monthly or per-hire fee to run your permanent hiring. Our guide to recruitment process outsourcing explains the model.

How Profitable Is a Staffing Agency?

Less than the markup suggests. Gross margin is what remains after the worker’s pay and employer costs, and it has to cover the entire business. Large publicly listed staffing companies typically report net profit margins in the single digits.

Profit grows with hours billed, so agencies prefer long assignments to short ones. That is why extensions are easy to arrange and conversions usually carry a fee. It is also a reason to set your own review point rather than letting an assignment renew by default.

What Buyers Should Do With This

Before you sign with a staffing agency: ask for the pay rate, set a review point, check conversion terms, match the model to the need

Ask for the pay rate as well as the bill rate. The gap is the markup. Agencies are often reluctant to share it, and that reluctance tells you something.

Set a review point. If an assignment passes six months, compare the cumulative markup against a conversion or a direct hire. If you are deciding before the assignment starts, compare contract to hire and direct hire on hiring risk first.

Check the conversion terms. Many agreements charge a fee to convert, reducing after a minimum period. Know the schedule from day one.

Match the model to the need. Temporary staffing is genuinely good for short projects, seasonal peaks and cover. It is expensive for permanent work.

When Paying the Markup Makes Sense

  • Seasonal or short-term demand. Flexibility has a real value when the work ends.
  • Compliance across many locations. The agency takes on employer obligations you would otherwise handle yourself.
  • Immediate starts. Agencies with ready workers can fill gaps within days.

For permanent roles, a one-time placement is usually cheaper. The structure is on the pricing page.

You can browse candidates on the client portal.

Our breakdown of how much recruiters charge covers the permanent-placement side.

Our analysis of accounting staffing agency costs shows how the markup adds up over three years in one function.

Sudberry Southern made a direct placement rather than running an ongoing agency assignment, and the Sudberry Southern case study covers the role.

If you would rather run recruiting yourself, see the recruiter role.

More on how hiring works is on the Pavago homepage.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do staffing agencies make money?

Mainly through a markup on contract and temporary workers, billing you more per hour than they pay the worker, and through one-time fees on permanent placements.

What is a typical staffing agency markup?

It varies widely by role, location, and employer costs. Much of it covers payroll taxes, insurance, and overhead rather than profit.

Do staffing agencies take money from the worker’s pay?

Legitimate agencies do not deduct a fee from the worker. They bill the client a higher rate than they pay the worker.

Is it cheaper to hire directly than through a staffing agency?

For permanent roles, usually yes, because a one-time fee replaces an hourly markup that continues as long as the assignment does.

Can I convert an agency worker to my own employee?

Usually, subject to a conversion fee or a minimum assignment period. Check the agreement before the assignment starts.

How profitable is a staffing agency?

After paying the worker, employer taxes, insurance and its own overhead, a staffing agency keeps a fairly small share of revenue. Large listed staffing companies typically report single-digit net profit margins.

What is payrolling?

Payrolling is when you find the worker yourself and a staffing agency acts as their legal employer, handling payroll, taxes and insurance for a lower markup than a full recruiting assignment.

What are the downsides of using a staffing agency?

The ongoing hourly markup, conversion fees if you want to keep the worker, and a smaller candidate pool for roles that might end. For permanent roles these usually cost more than a one-time placement fee.

Pay once, not every hour

Search the pool free. Messaging and interviews are free. 3% of first-year salary on placement, 60-day replacement.

Hammad leads SEO, content, and organic marketing at Pavago, a remote talent placement company. He has spent the past 5 years in B2B marketing, working across search, content strategy, and demand generation. At Pavago he owns the organic engine end to end, from technical SEO and keyword strategy to the launch content for Scout OS, the company's self-serve hiring marketplace. He writes about remote hiring, offshore teams, and what founders get wrong about both.